The Judges Judged

Discussion in 'UK Wine Forum' started by Alex Lake, Jun 6, 2018.

  1. Do we know that the person cititicizing the critics is a producer? Who, in fact, is he/she?

    Alex R.
     
  2. I think we all expect a bit of mutual back-scratching goes on, and anyone can make errors. But those allegations of impropriety and incompetence are very strong, and either false or damning. And the impropriety allegations reflect badly on the producers too.
     
  3. Tom Cannavan

    Tom Cannavan Administrator

    Oooh, don't know if I want that job!!! :) As you say, even though I understand the desire for anonymity, I would always treat the claims of an anonymous whistle blower with a bit of caution. Everyone on the list does have the right of public reply of course, and the means to do so if they choose.
     
    Phil David and johnny Shek like this.
  4. But it is fascinating all the same regardless of accuracy!
     
    Tom Cannavan likes this.

Share This Page