Piedmont at Terra Rossa, Islington N1

We were lucky. It was a bright evening on Wednesday in between the cool, rainy days we have been enduring.

Terra Rossa, in the heart of thriving Upper Street, did us proud and adapted the food continuously to our needs. I did not take notes, so these are just my impressions from memory.


Flight one - rose

  1. Roberto Garbarino Alta Langa Rose Dosagio Zero, 2016
  2. Nervi Rosato, 2018

Perfect way to start. Both wines are ideal summer/barbecue aperitifs, which is not to damn them with faint praise. I would love to own both and indeed ordered six of the #1 (£110/6 ib @Ultravino). It has a lively vibrant palate, while the Nervi has plenty of zesty red summer fruits - a top notch rose.


Flight two - whites/Timorasso

  1. Borgogno Timorasso, 2018
  2. Walter Massa Timorasso Derthona, 2016

Both excellent, and a little more serious than the F1 wines. Comparing the 16 Massa with the 18 Massa, which I recently acquired, it clearly benefits from some ageing. The Borgogno is a very rare specimen and shows great promise. Timorasso is a worthy and noble white variety, a genuine substitute for serious white burgundy, with more than a hint of white rhone.


Flight three: esoteric reds

  1. La Palazzina Bramaterra, 2010, magnum
  2. Vietti, La Crena, Barbera D’Asti, 2007

Two wines with a decent amount of age. The Vietti had an oxidative note but otherwise was a delight and a beautifully resolved mature Barbera, a variety which is easy to underestimate.The Palazzina Bramaterra from Alto Piedmonte was also a revelation. With only 12% alcohol, it is light on its feet, glides seamlessly across the palate and does not lack for depth, substance, and finish. The fact that this was a magnum and we finished it, in addition to the other 11 bottles, tells you all you need to know. Difficult to source, I did however manage to track down a few bottles of the 2013.


Flight four: 2016s

  1. Musso Barbaresco Pora, 2016
  2. Trediberri Barolo, 2016
  3. Burzi Barolo, 2016

The Musso was opened 3-4 hours in advance of drinking while the other two were popped and poured at the table and that dichotomy defined this flight. The Musso is a deep, brooding, serious, somewhat old school wine; full-bodied and intense with a strong backbone of acidity, it needs several years of cellaring. The Trediberri and the Burzi came across as lighter, prettier, more dextrous wines, both clearly very young. Of the two I preferred the Burzi, because I detected a bit of woodiness on the Trediberri. Both of these I would be happy to own, but I would not rush out and buy either now (given how many other 16 Barolos I have recently acquired). Neither impressed the way the Ettore Germano Cerretta did a few weeks ago. However, I am not sure, in hindsight, that popping and pouring them was ideal. For me the Musso was the pick of the flight, but I think I am in the minority there.


Flight five: 2009s (and a 1971)

  1. Oddero Bussia Mondoca, 2009
  2. Canonica Paiagallo, 2009
  3. Marchesi Di Barolo, Barolo, 1971

When I opened the Canonica around 4pm it was almost porty. It remained an uber ripe, alcoholic wine, which really pushes the envelope. It says 15% alcohol on the tin, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was a degree higher. It would have been interesting to revisit on day two, but it was hard work on day one. The Oddero was warm and inviting, in line with the vintage credentials, but in contrast was beautifully balanced and perfectly resolved. It was difficult to articulate further at that stage of the evening, but I think it benefitted from being opened in the morning. Overall my wine of the night. The Marchesi was a late addition and while still in the land of the living was well past its best. All you got was soil, and nothing else; the fruit had exited a long time ago.

The initial intention was to have 8-9 wines, between the 6 of us. I don’t know how we got up to 12 (13 bearing in mind we had a magnum). Nevertheless a fabulous evening, with great company. I only had to negotiate two hundreds metres of pavement to get home. I would not be surprised if the others did not remember their journey back.
 
Last edited:
Flight five: 2009s (and a 1971)

  1. Oddero Bussia Mondoca, 2009
  2. Canonica Paiagallo, 2009
  3. Marchesi Di Barolo, Barolo, 1971

When I opened the Canonica around 4pm it was almost porty. It remained an uber ripe, alcoholic wine, which really pushes the envelope. It says 15% alcohol on the tin, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was a degree higher. It would have been interesting to revisit on day two, but it was hard work on day one. The Oddero was warm and inviting, in line with the vintage credentials, but in contrast was beautifully balanced and perfectly resolved. It was difficult to articulate further at that stage of the evening, but I think it benefitted from being opened in the morning. Overall my wine of the night. The Marchesi was a late addition and while still in the land of the living was well past its best. All you got was soil, and nothing else; the fruit had exited a long time ago.
This is an excellent write up. It is also the n-th report questioning Canonica. It is also the n-th report which is highlighting high alcohol in Paiagallo. It is an east facing MGA in Barolo. I am not sure how this comes about. I have the same notes of alcoholic mess across many vintages. Alcoholic wines are after all are just that: wine with too much alcohol. Still very dubious of what Luigi Veronelli saw into this. I guess we all make some mistakes. Finally, and most importantly, I still have to encouter a notes which details Paiagallo as truly great wine (aside from a certain self-referential New York crew).
 
Ian thank you for organising this (and to all for their generosity and company). It was a wonderful evening. I agree that there was possibly too much wine but in situations like this as someone has said - small pours are your friend. My journey home was fine and I felt relatively clear headed in the morning although then my cycle ride into town was not a success...

We were lucky with the wines, we had outstanding commentary from Mark and Simon, and I got more from the Marchesi than you managed. The white flight was outstanding and the first flight of reds was a revelation. I am quite glad I have a few more bottles of the Oddero. I look forward to the next outing.
 
The Trediberri and the Burzi came across as lighter, prettier, more dextrous wines, both clearly very young. Of the two I preferred the Burzi, because I detected a bit of woodiness on the Trediberri. Both of these I would be happy to own, but I would not rush out and buy either now (given how many other 16 Barolos I have recently acquired). Neither impressed the way the Ettore Germano Cerretta did a few weeks ago. However, I am not sure, in hindsight, that popping and pouring them was ideal.
Firstly, thanks for the notes Ian. A shame to miss this one but I have had some vicarious pleasure.

I opened my sole bottle of Burzi ‘16 this evening and am sure pop ‘n’ pour was not optimal. It started out perfectly decent at 5pm - clean, pure fruited but lacking complexity and a bit dull if I am honest. Nothing at all wrong with it, it just didn’t excite me. I am now finishing the last glass (5 hours later) and it is really so much better - seems darker in colour, more going on aromatically (including some spices), palate more complex (deeper fruit flavours, some herbacious notes and a touch of licourice) and overall better balance. Looks like I may need to reevaluate my view that young Barolo is more likely to close than open with air, although I will probably find an opposite data point shortly! Overall a very good wine for the price.
 
Thank you Ian for the excellent write-up. Terra Rossa was a very homely Puglian Italian restaurant where the service was impeccable and the waiting staff kind and attentive and value for money second to none. The culinary experience was really good too and just what one needed to accompany the wines. As Ian says they kept the dishes coming and amongst my favourites were the pasta based dishes but there was also octopus and pizza too - and much fun because of the tapas style dining format.

In terms of the wines it is always hard to get a proper view on any particular wine when there are 11 bottles + 1 magnum and they are each drunk over a 30 to 45 minute period which may be sub-optimal and there are also other factors at play, e.g. whether decanted or PnP - as @Oliver Coleman-Green alluded to with the Burzi above.

I am a big fan of the Roberto Gabarino Alta Langa Rose yet I didn't think it really had the chance to unfurl (as it did when I enjoyed it last night with sea bream bbq etc.) but was still interesting and all the more savoury when paired next to the Nervi Conterno Rosado which was decent if not entirely memorable.

The white flight was better than I was expecting as I have not had a good run lately with Piedmont whites, the Massa 2016 was my standout as it was full of energy and zingyness (a bit like Pieropan is - although Simon did not find this at all in his glass) and a good level of complexity. I was less keen on the Timorasso which I found a bit too fruity and less interesting - although perfectly decent.

The 2010 Bramaterra was my WOTN and fantastic of Mark to bring an odd-ball wine (a "Super-Piedmont" - okay I have invented that - to reflect the grape composition of 70% Nebbiolo and the remainder other indiginous unrecognisable varietals) en magnum and steal the show. This was simply a joy to drink - absolutely delicious, refreshing, lovely fruit, energy, complexity and a lovely finish. I said to others when commenting on the wines that it seemed invigorating and almost could be a health drink (meant in the very best possible way). A magnum of Bramaterra preceded by a champagne would indeed be perfect for two gentleman dining over lunch. Regarding the 07 Vietti La Crena Barbera - I did not really get it at all - Simon had to lose about a quarter of the bottle to sediment when decanting and the only thing I detect get on the nose was earth and I could not find the appeal that others seemed to experience, it seemed a bit overdone to me, and lacked the enjoyment I have found in other Barbera's (thinking here Bartolo, Voerzio, Vajra etc.).

The 2016 reds were interesting although slightly under whelming (please refer to my second paragraph above) and I found the Musso Pora seemed to conform to its Barbaresco appellation in terms of fragrance and sensuality and I found it quite light on its feet although as Ian says quite acidic and in need of cellaring. The Trediberri and Burzi were more typically Barolo in terms of power and structure although whilst they were drinkable and enjoyable it seemed like they could either have been more interesting if studied and allowed to develop over the evening or if given a few more years. I would put them about level pegging in terms of which was best and I did not really detect any oak in the Trediberri which was perhaps a tiny bit floral and sensuous compared with the Burzi that seemed more powerful and structured.

The final flight was very interesting. I positively loved the Oddero Bussia and it showed that in 2009 there is great Baroli out there as I know from having bought and enjoyed Cogno's Pernice (this was my no.2 wine of the night). The Oddero has energy some complexity, nicely integrated wood and I am sure that a whole bottle over the course of an evening would have been an absolute delight. I am afraid that the 2009 Canonica was not my cup of tea at all and whilst I got menthol on the nose it seemed like it was picked too late and vinified with a heavy hand - resulting in an extreme wine that was not enjoyable to drink and showed every percentage point of its 15% ABV and more. The 1971 Marchesi was a treat to try and kind of Ian to run back home especially and the bottle was not shot yet the wine was more interesting (in an old-winey way) than enjoyable.

Overall a memorable evening where everything seemed to fit together well and in very good company - and very glad that I had a decent quantity of pizza to help wash down the last flight.
 
Last edited:
Late to the party on this with my thoughts as I was to the offline itself! I'm blaming the W7 bus from Crouch End! :rolleyes:

I really liked Terra Rossa ( a Puglian restaurant that I'd not visited before). Staff were friendly and accommodating, food was tasty and there was plenty of it to soak up our fine array of Piedmont offerings and it was a great value. What's not to like.

Many thanks to Ian for putting this great offline together; a really fun evening all round.

The 2016 Garbarino Alta Langa Rose (zero dosage) (100% Pinot Nero) 12.5% was a good way to kick off the evenings festivities; sappy, fresh, vibrant, red fruited and elegant.

2018 Conterno Nervi II Rosato (100% Nebbiolo) 13.5%
Quite a serious Rose; attractive perfumed notes. Very dry and quite saline on the finish.

Some really interesting Piedmont Whites out there if you fancy a bit of a hunting mission. Timorasso is a variety well worth seeking out and I was pleased that we had two on show to compare and contrast. Both wines were on the youthful side but with promising futures ahead of them with further cellaring I feel.

2018 Borgogno "Derthona" (100% Timorasso) 14%
Distinctive lanolin, orange blossom, herbal notes and white flowers all spring to mind when you take a sniff. Quite soft in style, crisp and very high acidity. Quite a lean, herbal character on the palate.

2016 Massa "Derthona" (100% Timorasso) 14%
Compared with the Borgogno this was not particularly expressive; some grapey aromatics and not much else. Roll it around your tongue and mouth though and feel the wine just come alive. It's energetic, sappy, citrusy, oily, rich, texturally very impressive with layers of flavour building as it opens up. Would love to try this with 10 years bottle age on it as I think its going to be fabulous.

We ate a Octopus Carpaccio with the two Whites and this was a perfect food/wine match I must say.

Now for the Reds (lots of them!) o_O

2010 La Palazzina Bramaterra (Nebbiolo, Croatina, Vespolina, Uva Rara) 12.5% MAGNUM
A Magnum on first glance probably seemed a little excessive for a Wednesday "school night" but I talked myself into bringing it as one it was my first offline of the year and second I thought that the Bramaterra would be a good place drinking wise; happy to report that it was. This is the sort of wine that truly encapsulates what Piedmont is all about; it was a joy to share this. Everything in harmony; tannin, acidity, fruit, alcohol. Complex but not intellectual. Perfumed; clove, cinnamon and aniseed notes; balsamic and dried lapsang tea leaves, smoky, cherry/redcurrant fruited. Layered and with lots of energy and all this for only 12.5% alcohol! I think that if we had had a jeroboam of this wine we would have drunk it all.

2007 Vietti Barbera d'Asti "La Crena" (100% Barbera) 14.5%
Big wine this; rich and burly and too me a little unbalanced and a bit soupy. Showing its age

A trio of 2016 Nebbiolo's up next. Lovely to try all these wines but they were all far too young for my taste.

2016 Musso Barbaresco "Pora" (100% Nebbiolo) 14.5%
Surprisingly forward this; very perfumed. Light and fresh in style. Plenty of acidity which I'm a fan of

2016 Trediberri Barolo (100% Nebbiolo) 14%
Attractive red fruited style. Seemed quite open initially but after a while the structure told hold and rather shut it everything down.

2016 Burzi Barolo (100% Nebbiolo) 14.%%
Very powerful and structured at this point and not really giving much away at this stage

I think my palate was feeling a little jaded by the time we got to the final three Reds which was a shame I felt as I don't feel that I really did them justice. A Moscato d'Asti/Brachetto d'Acqui interlude may have helped at this point! In hindsight perhaps we should have dropped the 3 x 2016s and gone straight to these wines after the Bramaterra/Barbera flight.

2009 Oddero Barolo (100% Nebbiolo) 14.5%
Inviting and very expressive with notes of old wood, furniture polish and boozy Christmas cake. It definitely shows that warm 2009 vintage character but it has freshness and lift and was in a nice drinking phase.

2009 Canonica Paiagallo Barolo (100% Nebbiolo) 15%
Volatile, dried out, port like and completely out of balance.

IMG_1783.JPG

IMG_1784.JPG

IMG_1785.JPG

IMG_1786.JPG

IMG_1787.JPG

IMG_1788.JPG
 
Top